10
edits
WikiIslam:Discussions/Archive: Difference between revisions
m
Responding to question.
No edit summary |
m (Responding to question.) |
||
| Line 80: | Line 80: | ||
[[Category:WikiIslam]] | [[Category:WikiIslam]] | ||
== Abu Jahal, Ikriban Ibn Abi Jahl and /or One Islam Productions == | ==Abu Jahal, Ikriban Ibn Abi Jahl and /or One Islam Productions== | ||
One Islam Productions's "4 Stories That Tell Us Who Prophet Muhammad Really Was! Emotional Video" starts off by saying that Abu Jahal had killed Muslims for no other reason than because they were believers. The video then goes on to talk about the kindness of Muhammad to his son, Ikribin Ibn Abi Jahl. I have come to be skeptical of Muslim claims that in Mohammad's time there were people who killed Muslims without provocation. It would be interesting to see an article addressing this claim about Abu Jahal. | One Islam Productions's "4 Stories That Tell Us Who Prophet Muhammad Really Was! Emotional Video" starts off by saying that Abu Jahal had killed Muslims for no other reason than because they were believers. The video then goes on to talk about the kindness of Muhammad to his son, Ikribin Ibn Abi Jahl. I have come to be skeptical of Muslim claims that in Mohammad's time there were people who killed Muslims without provocation. It would be interesting to see an article addressing this claim about Abu Jahal. | ||
:Wikiislam certainly requires an article on Abu Jahl - the accusations made against him and similar characters in the Sira certainly merit analysis, particularly from a historical-critical perspective. Would you like to get started on it? You could address the topic from either a traditional or historical-critical standpoint, whatever you prefer, or both. Not sure what your editorial privileges are at the moment, but I can make a sandbox for you to get started on a draft if you'd like. [[User:IbnPinker|IbnPinker]] ([[User talk:IbnPinker|talk]]) 16:37, 7 April 2021 (UTC) | :Wikiislam certainly requires an article on Abu Jahl - the accusations made against him and similar characters in the Sira certainly merit analysis, particularly from a historical-critical perspective. Would you like to get started on it? You could address the topic from either a traditional or historical-critical standpoint, whatever you prefer, or both. Not sure what your editorial privileges are at the moment, but I can make a sandbox for you to get started on a draft if you'd like. [[User:IbnPinker|IbnPinker]] ([[User talk:IbnPinker|talk]]) 16:37, 7 April 2021 (UTC) | ||
I agree that it's quite reasonable to ask someone making a suggestion if they would be able to do it. After all, ideas are always more plentiful than volunteer sweat. However, I am over-committed at the moment. | |||