823
edits
Qur'anic Christology: Difference between revisions
m
→See Also: Adding in two reputable and relevant YouTube videos for links (can't seem to get rid off the space between the previous bullet point due to a template).
| [checked revision] | [checked revision] |
No edit summary |
m (→See Also: Adding in two reputable and relevant YouTube videos for links (can't seem to get rid off the space between the previous bullet point due to a template).) |
||
| (2 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{QualityScore|Lead=1|Structure=2|Content=3|Language=2|References=2}} | {{QualityScore|Lead=1|Structure=2|Content=3|Language=2|References=2}} | ||
This article examines some of the problems that have been pointed out in [[Qur'an|Qur'anic]] [[w:Christology|Christology]]. | This article examines some of the problems that have been pointed out in [[Qur'an|Qur'anic]] [[w:Christology|Christology]]. | ||
== | ==Qur'anic Christology of Jesus' Essence== | ||
There can be no doubt that the Qur'an does not accept the Christian position that Jesus Christ was the Son of God or any Incarnation of God at all. [[Surah]] 19 states that to regard Jesus as Son of God is one of the worse sins according to [[Islam]]. | There can be no doubt that the Qur'an does not accept the Christian position that Jesus Christ was the Son of God or any Incarnation of God at all. [[Surah]] 19 states that to regard Jesus as Son of God is one of the worse sins according to [[Islam]]. | ||
| Line 23: | Line 23: | ||
In the following chapters, we will see that in fact all of this information about Jesus in the Qur'an derives from Christian sources with only little differences and almost no additions. | In the following chapters, we will see that in fact all of this information about Jesus in the Qur'an derives from Christian sources with only little differences and almost no additions. | ||
== | ==The Virgin Birth== | ||
However, surprisingly, and in stark contrast to the Jewish belief, the Qur'an recognizes Jesus as messiah: | However, surprisingly, and in stark contrast to the Jewish belief, the Qur'an recognizes Jesus as messiah: | ||
| Line 31: | Line 31: | ||
This fact is of great importance since the term "Messiah" is just the Hebrew translation of "Christ" (the anointed one). Thus, we can begin to talk about a Qur'anic Christology. However, it does not necessarily mean that Jesus is the son of God, like most Christians believe. | This fact is of great importance since the term "Messiah" is just the Hebrew translation of "Christ" (the anointed one). Thus, we can begin to talk about a Qur'anic Christology. However, it does not necessarily mean that Jesus is the son of God, like most Christians believe. | ||
The reason is that the term Messiah has many different meanings in Judaism and Christianity. Jewish people usually refer to a Messiah as the promised king, prophet or religious leader of | The reason is that the term Messiah has many different meanings in Judaism and Christianity. Jewish people usually refer to a Messiah as the promised king, prophet or religious leader of Israel, the one who leads the Jewish people out of oppression. In Christianity - on the other hand - the word has become almost a synonym for the son of God in whom all promises are fulfilled. | ||
But what kind of messiah is the Qur'an talking about? A Jewish king? A Jewish prophet? The Christian redeemer? To be honest, the fact that the Qur'an calls Jesus a Messiah does not necessarily imply that he is or has ever been the son of God; however, it can easily lead to confusion and misunderstandings. One might ask in what way the term Messiah serves the Islamic idea that Jesus was only a human being. In other words: Is it useful in any manner for the authors of the Qur'an to accept that Jesus was the Christ? It further seems that someone labeled "Christ" could be a mere prophet, as the Messiah is commonly understood to play a dominant role in [[w:apocalyptic|apocalyptic]] speculations. | But what kind of messiah is the Qur'an talking about? A Jewish king? A Jewish prophet? The Christian redeemer? To be honest, the fact that the Qur'an calls Jesus a Messiah does not necessarily imply that he is or has ever been the son of God; however, it can easily lead to confusion and misunderstandings. One might ask in what way the term Messiah serves the Islamic idea that Jesus was only a human being. In other words: Is it useful in any manner for the authors of the Qur'an to accept that Jesus was the Christ? It further seems that someone labeled "Christ" could be a mere prophet, as the Messiah is commonly understood to play a dominant role in [[w:apocalyptic|apocalyptic]] speculations. | ||
| Line 50: | Line 50: | ||
Instead, the author of the Qur'an seems to conflate the legend with their own understanding of historical reality. This would not be surprising for a commoner from the middle ages, but it is perhaps surprising coming from Muhammad, the final messenger. | Instead, the author of the Qur'an seems to conflate the legend with their own understanding of historical reality. This would not be surprising for a commoner from the middle ages, but it is perhaps surprising coming from Muhammad, the final messenger. | ||
== | ==Jesus as the Word of God== | ||
And there is more. In Surah 4:171 Jesus is also clearly referred to as Word of God. | And there is more. In Surah 4:171 Jesus is also clearly referred to as Word of God. | ||
| Line 65: | Line 65: | ||
The author of the Qur'an, it would seem, is not aware of this more sophistical meaning of "word", otherwise he may have avoided this expression which would seem to challenge the idea that Jesus was mere man. Furthermore, if Jesus is the "word" of God, then what is the status of the Qur'an, which also alleges to be the "word" of the God? The basic idea that Jesus is the "word" of appears rather problematic to Islamic theology. | The author of the Qur'an, it would seem, is not aware of this more sophistical meaning of "word", otherwise he may have avoided this expression which would seem to challenge the idea that Jesus was mere man. Furthermore, if Jesus is the "word" of God, then what is the status of the Qur'an, which also alleges to be the "word" of the God? The basic idea that Jesus is the "word" of appears rather problematic to Islamic theology. | ||
== | ==Jesus Creating Living Creatures== | ||
In Surah 3:59 Jesus is described as equal to Adam (who is also called prophet in the Qur'an) who was made from dust. | In Surah 3:59 Jesus is described as equal to Adam (who is also called prophet in the Qur'an) who was made from dust. | ||
| Line 91: | Line 91: | ||
And it is even more astonishing, that the Qur'an renders this record in a very close neighborhood to the account of the creation of Adam. Drawing this parallel between god's creation of Adam and Jesus's creation of birds, both from lifeless clay, would once more seem to be ill-suited to Islamic theology. | And it is even more astonishing, that the Qur'an renders this record in a very close neighborhood to the account of the creation of Adam. Drawing this parallel between god's creation of Adam and Jesus's creation of birds, both from lifeless clay, would once more seem to be ill-suited to Islamic theology. | ||
==Gnostic | ==Possible Gnostic Influence== | ||
In Surah 4:157 the Qur'an claims that not Jesus, but somebody else was [[Crucifixion|crucified]]. | In Surah 4:157 the Qur'an claims that not Jesus, but somebody else was [[Crucifixion|crucified]]. | ||
| Line 111: | Line 111: | ||
Interestingly, the greek term "doceo" can be translated with "to seem" or "to appear as" which is also expressed in {{Quran|4|157}}. Therefore, it is indeed very likely, that the author of the Qur'an drew this words from ancient gnostic texts. This, too, struggles to find a comfortable home in Islamic theology. | Interestingly, the greek term "doceo" can be translated with "to seem" or "to appear as" which is also expressed in {{Quran|4|157}}. Therefore, it is indeed very likely, that the author of the Qur'an drew this words from ancient gnostic texts. This, too, struggles to find a comfortable home in Islamic theology. | ||
== | ==Assumption into Heaven and Miraculous Powers== | ||
Whether he was truly crucified or not, Qur'an, gnosis and the canonical Christians all well agree in the concept that Jesus was raised to heaven. | Whether he was truly crucified or not, Qur'an, gnosis and the canonical Christians all well agree in the concept that Jesus was raised to heaven. | ||
| Line 138: | Line 138: | ||
{{Hub4|Jesus|Jesus}} | {{Hub4|Jesus|Jesus}} | ||
*[[Corruption of Previous Scriptures]] | *[[Corruption of Previous Scriptures]] | ||
* [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6ESfQpmmVig islamwhattheydonttellyou164 - Christian Teachings in the Quran] - ''YouTube Video'' | |||
* [https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=islamwhattheydonttellyou164 islamwhattheydonttellyou164 - Jesus as Isa: The Honest Truth] - ''YouTube Video'' | |||
==Further Reading== | ==Further Reading== | ||