Sanggahan Terhadap Apologis Muslim Mengenai Usia Aisha: Difference between revisions

[checked revision][checked revision]
Line 44: Line 44:
===Argumen Kedua===
===Argumen Kedua===


{{Quote|1=[http://www.understanding-islam.com/ri/mi-005.htm Moiz Amjad]|2=It is quite strange that no one from Medinah, where Hisham ibn `urwah lived the first seventy one years of his life has narrated the event [from him], even though in Medinah his pupils included people as well known as Malik ibn Anas. All the narratives of this event have been reported by narrators from Iraq, where Hisham is reported to have had shifted after living in Medinah for seventy one years.}}
{{Quote|1=[http://www.understanding-islam.com/ri/mi-005.htm Moiz Amjad]|2=Cukup aneh bahwa tidak seorangpun dari Medinah, di mana Hisham ibn 'urwah tinggal selama tujuh puluh satu tahun pertama hidupnya yang meneruskan kisah [dari dirinya], padahal di Medinah dia memiliki murid-murid yang dikenal luas seperti Malik ibn Anas. Semua narasi atas kisah ini telah dilaporkan oleh penerus kisah dari Iraq, di mana Hisham kabarnya telah pindah setelah sempat tinggal di Medinah selama tujuh puluh satu tahun.}}


Another ''Straw man''. There is no requirement for a hadith to be narrated in Medina for it to be considered sahih. Also, many events in the Prophet’s life were narrated by single narratives as well. Does that make them invalid? No. To demand multiple, independent narrations from Medinans is just setting up a standard that does not exist – i.e. a straw man.
Another ''Straw man''. There is no requirement for a hadith to be narrated in Medina for it to be considered sahih. Also, many events in the Prophet’s life were narrated by single narratives as well. Does that make them invalid? No. To demand multiple, independent narrations from Medinans is just setting up a standard that does not exist – i.e. a straw man.
Editors, em-bypass-2, Reviewers
39

edits