WikiIslam:Writing Style Guide: Difference between revisions

Jump to navigation Jump to search
mNo edit summary
(3 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 142: Line 142:
|Heaven
|Heaven
|-
|-
|'''Jahanam'''
|'''Jahannam'''
|No
|No
|Hell
|Hell
Line 170: Line 170:
|Lesser holy pilgrimage in Islam
|Lesser holy pilgrimage in Islam
|-
|-
|'''Kaaba'''
|'''Ka'bah'''
|Yes
|Yes
|Building at the center of Masjid al-Haram in Mecca. Direction of Muslim prayers and destination of pilgrimage
|Building at the center of Masjid al-Haram in Mecca. Direction of Muslim prayers and destination of pilgrimage
Line 178: Line 178:
|Circumcision
|Circumcision
|-
|-
|'''Najis'''
|'''Najs'''
|No
|No
|Ritually unclean or impure physically or spiritually
|Ritually unclean or impure physically or spiritually
Line 206: Line 206:
|Non-Mutawatir hadith, usually narrated by one narrator
|Non-Mutawatir hadith, usually narrated by one narrator
|-
|-
|'''Sharia'''
|'''Shari'ah'''
|No
|No
|Islamic canonical law based on Islamic scriptures
|Islamic canonical law based on Islamic scriptures
Line 286: Line 286:
|Obligatory charity based on % wealth
|Obligatory charity based on % wealth
|-
|-
|'''Dawah'''
|'''Da'wah'''
|No
|No
|Islamic proselytizing
|Islamic proselytizing
Line 418: Line 418:
|An editor's own conclusions or exaggerations are being replaced with facts.
|An editor's own conclusions or exaggerations are being replaced with facts.
|}
|}
===Modern Views of Traditional Islamic Topics===
Islam, as with any storied tradition, has and continues to change with the times. What a Muslim scholar wrote in a book in 10th century Baghdad is not going to perfectly reflect the beliefs and practices of Muslims living on the West Coast of the United States in the current year. The beliefs of both and in fact all other Muslims fall within the scope and purview of WikiIslam, and it is the wiki's job to document both.
When it comes to the arguments of modern Islamic du'aah (preachers) and apologists however special care is needed. The wiki shall concern itself with documenting such arguments as reach a critical mass of recognition in the Muslim community at large, and will present them clearly and in an unbiased fashion. Where these arguments contradict obvious readings of the original texts, contradict published and accepted science, or generally err in regards to the facts these errors shall be enumerated and commented upon, but the wiki will not concern itself with making persuasive arguments as to the merits of these apologetic claims, one way or another. Likewise, when a commonly held modern view in the contemporary Muslim community contradicts a plain reading of the text or provable history, these discrepancies too shall be catalogued, but it is once again not the wiki's job to make a persuasive argument for or against such views. For more information on which apologetic claims can be included for discussion on the wiki, please see [[WikiIslam:Scope and Article Relevance]]. For more on how the analysis of these modern views should be incorporated into the article, please see [[WikiIslam:Structure]]


==Lead vs Body==
==Lead vs Body==
Line 432: Line 438:


Where a source is open to interpretation or is disputed, editors should not assume a particular meaning. Interpretations can be discussed by reference to scholars. The editor should only seek to summarize and collect sources that accurately reflect the positions and dialogue concerning the article’s subject.  Articles should ''never'' end with an evaluation of the editor’s impression, as this constitutes original research. They should, however, summarize the conclusions of the scholarly works and the plain readings of the primary sources cited.
Where a source is open to interpretation or is disputed, editors should not assume a particular meaning. Interpretations can be discussed by reference to scholars. The editor should only seek to summarize and collect sources that accurately reflect the positions and dialogue concerning the article’s subject.  Articles should ''never'' end with an evaluation of the editor’s impression, as this constitutes original research. They should, however, summarize the conclusions of the scholarly works and the plain readings of the primary sources cited.
==Modern Views of Traditional Islamic Topics==
Islam, as any great tradition, has and continues to change with the times. What a Muslim scholar wrote in a book in 10th century Baghdad is not going to perfectly reflect the beliefs and practices of Muslims living on the West Coast of the United States in the current year. The beliefs of both and in fact all other Muslims fall within the scope and purview of WikiIslam, and it is the wiki's job to document both. When it comes to the arguments of modern Islamic du'aah (preachers) and apologists however special care is needed. The wiki shall concern itself with documenting such arguments as reach a critical mass of recognition in the Muslim community at large, and will present them clearly and in an unbiased fashion. Where these arguments contradict obvious readings of the original texts, contradict published and accepted science, or generally err in regards to the facts these errors shall be enumerated and commented upon, but the wiki will not concern itself with making persuasive arguments as to the merits of these apologetic claims, one way or another. Likewise, when a commonly held modern view in the contemporary Muslim community contradicts a plain reading of the text or provable history, these discrepancies too shall be catalogued, but it is once again not the wiki's job to make a persuasive argument for or against such views. For more information on which apologetic claims can be included for discussion on the wiki, please see [[WikiIslam:Scope and Article Relevance]].


==Transliteration==
==Transliteration==
Line 441: Line 443:


===Title===
===Title===
For titles of transliterated words use the standardized transliteration as the title with the English translation in brackets next to it. Example: Jannah (Heaven)
For titles of transliterated words use the standardized transliteration as the title with the English translation in brackets next to it. Example: Jannah (Heaven) For more info, please see [[WikiIslam:Titles]]


===Article===
===Article===
Editors, recentchangescleanup, Reviewers
4,539

edits

Navigation menu