Main Page

From WikiIslam, the online resource on Islam
Jump to: navigation, search


Welcome to WikiIslam,
a resource to critically examine history, texts and beliefs within Islam
2,177 articles hosted on WikiIslam
Please note: Many of the very problematic issues and views within Islam and its history are often rejected or subject to widely varying knowledge and opinions (if any) by Muslim cultures and many people who identify as Muslim today


Essay: Rejecting the "Aisha Was Older" Apologetic Myth

Muslim, Christian and Jew.jpg

Some well-intentioned people are claiming that "Most scholars for the last 1200 years suggest Aisha was 11-14 at the time of the consummation of her marriage to Muhammad", and one person even provided a link to an apologetic piece by Dr. David Liepert at the Huffington Post titled, "Rejecting the Myth of Sanctioned Child Marriage in Islam".

Apparently the arguments raised by Liepert and others have given many the false impression that Aisha's age is a long contested issue in Islam, and that it is a valid argument over interpretation that could eventually lead to reforms within mainstream Islam. The problem I have with this, is that it is certainly not an argument over interpretation.

The text clearly say one thing and one thing only. For anyone with a little knowledge on the subject and who has actually read the source material, it is disingenuous to claim otherwise. For people like Liepert, simply lying about what sources say may be effective in apologetic pieces, but they are useless if the intentions behind them are to reform the religion. (read more)

Hub Pages:
Abdullah AzzamAbrogationAdulteryAishaAlcoholAllahAmputationAnimalsAntisemitismApologistsAtheistsBanu QurayzaBeautyBin LadenBook ReviewsCartoonsChildrenConspiraciesContradictions and ErrorsConvertsCorruption of ScriptureCosmologyCreationCritics of IslamDhimmitudeDhul-QarnaynDrinksEmbryologyFake ConversionsFarewell SermonFastingFoodFree SpeechGabriel‎GeniesGenocideGolden AgeHadithHarun YahyaHealthHeavenHellHelp & AdviceHijabHoaxesHonor ViolenceHuman RightsHygieneI. A. IbrahimIbn WarraqImagesIslamic ClericsIslamic TermsJesusJihadistsJizyahLegendsLibraryLinksListsLiteratureLogical FallaciesLyingMahrMarriageMaryMathematical MiraclesMichael H. HartMilkMischiefMisinterpreted VersesMistranslated VersesMoonMoon Split MiracleMosquesMuhammadMuhammad's DeathMuhammad in Other ScripturesMuhammad's RevelationsMuhammad's WivesMusicMuslim BrotherhoodNatural DisastersNazismNewsNon-MuslimsPact of UmarPaganismPareidoliaPersecutionPersecution by CountryPhilosophyPhobiaPolygamyPornographyPrayersPredestinationPublic FiguresPunishmentsQuizzes & GamesQuotationsQur'anRacismRapeRashad KhalifaRefutationsReproductionRevelationsSalafSatanic VersesSexShari'ahShi'itesSlaverySoft DrinksStoningTabari‎TaxesTerrorismTimelinesTop 10 ListsTu QuoqueUnderstanding the Qur'anUrineViolence Against WomenViolence by MuhammadVirginsWebsitesWife BeatingWitchcraftZakir NaikZakatZamzam