Difference between revisions of "Allah and Muhammad in the Clouds"

From WikiIslam, the online resource on Islam
Jump to: navigation, search
[checked revision][checked revision]
m
(References)
 
(7 intermediate revisions by one other user not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
 
==Allah==
 
==Allah==
  
===Muslim  claim===
+
===Miracle Claim===
  
 
Some Muslims claim that these clouds spell out "[[Allah]]".  
 
Some Muslims claim that these clouds spell out "[[Allah]]".  
Line 12: Line 12:
 
Images can easily be doctored by using Photoshop or a similar software program. Even if we accept the image is genuine, we have to consider the fact that cloud formations are constantly changing and are therefore limitless in design, making them an easy source of pareidolia. The image that is recognized by the viewer is dependent upon the angle and time at which the cloud is being viewed from, and hence the photo.
 
Images can easily be doctored by using Photoshop or a similar software program. Even if we accept the image is genuine, we have to consider the fact that cloud formations are constantly changing and are therefore limitless in design, making them an easy source of pareidolia. The image that is recognized by the viewer is dependent upon the angle and time at which the cloud is being viewed from, and hence the photo.
  
Furthermore, the lettering in this photo is different in style to the lettering found within other "miraculous" images spelling out Allah (e.g. the [[Honeycomb Allah|bees-wax]]) even though they are all supposed to be creating the same word. If these pictures are instances of a deity writing his own name, then all his writings should be very similar in style; but they are not. Those who claim that these are miraculous signs from Allah, need to explain why they differ so much in style. Surely they are written by the same hand?  
+
Furthermore, the lettering in this photo is different in style to the lettering found within other "miraculous" images spelling out Allah (e.g. the [[Allah Written In or On Various Things#Bees_Spell_Out_Allah|bees-wax]]) even though they are all supposed to be creating the same word. If these pictures are instances of a deity writing his own name, then all his writings should be very similar in style; but they are not. Those who claim that these are miraculous signs from Allah, need to explain why they differ so much in style. Surely they are written by the same hand?
  
 
==Muhammad==
 
==Muhammad==
  
===Muslim  claim===
+
===Miracle Claim===
 
<center>[[Image:Muhammed-in-the-clouds.jpg|400px]]</center>
 
<center>[[Image:Muhammed-in-the-clouds.jpg|400px]]</center>
 +
  
 
{{quote || During the speech by Dr. Muhammad Tahir-ul-Qadri on the international Mawlid-un-Nabi Conference on the 12th Rabbi Ul Awwal the word MUHAMMAD appeared near the Moon...just as the Shaykh was spelling the name and said "I wish i had a board to write it on" ...Subhannallah!! The clouds wrote it for him!! <ref>[http://www.metacafe.com/watch/yt-VBUs1ZPddB8/the_word_muhammad_in_the_sky_milad_un_nabi/ MetaCafe - Miracle video description]</ref><ref>[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUs1ZPddB8 Youtube - Miracle video description]</ref><ref>[http://yasayyidi.wordpress.com/2007/12/03/the-word-muhammad-salilahu-alaihi-wassalam-in-the-sky/ Blog containing Miracle video]</ref>}}
 
{{quote || During the speech by Dr. Muhammad Tahir-ul-Qadri on the international Mawlid-un-Nabi Conference on the 12th Rabbi Ul Awwal the word MUHAMMAD appeared near the Moon...just as the Shaykh was spelling the name and said "I wish i had a board to write it on" ...Subhannallah!! The clouds wrote it for him!! <ref>[http://www.metacafe.com/watch/yt-VBUs1ZPddB8/the_word_muhammad_in_the_sky_milad_un_nabi/ MetaCafe - Miracle video description]</ref><ref>[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUs1ZPddB8 Youtube - Miracle video description]</ref><ref>[http://yasayyidi.wordpress.com/2007/12/03/the-word-muhammad-salilahu-alaihi-wassalam-in-the-sky/ Blog containing Miracle video]</ref>}}
Line 74: Line 75:
  
 
==See Also==
 
==See Also==
* [[Allah in the Sky]]
+
 
 +
* [[Animals Marked by Allah]]
 +
{{Hub4|Hoaxes|Hoaxes}}
  
 
==External links==
 
==External links==
Line 82: Line 85:
 
== References ==
 
== References ==
 
{{reflist}}
 
{{reflist}}
 +
 +
[[bg:Аллах и Мухаммад в облаците)]]

Latest revision as of 10:07, 29 June 2015

Miracles
GeorgicsMathematical Miracles
Moon Split ImagesCat's Eye Nebula in the Qur'an
Speed of Light
Pareidolia
Animals Marked by AllahAllah in the Sky
Tomato with ShahadahAllah on a Fish
Allah in an Egg PlantRight Hand Spells Out Allah
Allah in the Ear
Hoaxes
Baby with Qur'anic Verses10 Meter Human Skeleton
Trees Spells ShahadahBronchus Resembles Shahadah
Shariff IddFake ConversionsPraying Tree
Muhammad in the CloudsBees Spell Out Allah
Cactus Spell Out AllahAllah in a Melon
Miscellaneous
Standing MosquesDog Responds to the Adhan
Google Earth Proves Islam
Articles
A Qur’anic UniverseMuhammad's Miracles
Witnessing the Moon Splitting Miracle

Allah

Miracle Claim

Some Muslims claim that these clouds spell out "Allah".

Allahclouds.jpg

Analysis

Images can easily be doctored by using Photoshop or a similar software program. Even if we accept the image is genuine, we have to consider the fact that cloud formations are constantly changing and are therefore limitless in design, making them an easy source of pareidolia. The image that is recognized by the viewer is dependent upon the angle and time at which the cloud is being viewed from, and hence the photo.

Furthermore, the lettering in this photo is different in style to the lettering found within other "miraculous" images spelling out Allah (e.g. the bees-wax) even though they are all supposed to be creating the same word. If these pictures are instances of a deity writing his own name, then all his writings should be very similar in style; but they are not. Those who claim that these are miraculous signs from Allah, need to explain why they differ so much in style. Surely they are written by the same hand?

Muhammad

Miracle Claim

Muhammed-in-the-clouds.jpg


During the speech by Dr. Muhammad Tahir-ul-Qadri on the international Mawlid-un-Nabi Conference on the 12th Rabbi Ul Awwal the word MUHAMMAD appeared near the Moon...just as the Shaykh was spelling the name and said "I wish i had a board to write it on" ...Subhannallah!! The clouds wrote it for him!! [1][2][3]

Analysis

Video and Translation

What we have here is a little creative license when presenting a miracle. The above quote claims that the Shaykh said he wished he had a board to write on and then the miracle occurred. Well, not quite. Here is the video and English translation of the event:

Labz-e-muhammad: The word 'Muhammad'

kahiye: Say! (the word Muhammad)

sub kahiye: everyone say (the word Muhammad)

boliye: speak (the word 'Muhammad')

yaa harf aaya hai meem phir aa uske baad phir meem phir daal: The word starts with meem then aaa after that meem again then daal

[He gets interrupted by the other person who is pointing towards the moon in the sky]

bata rahe hai ki badalon mein allah pak ne isme muhammad ko likh diya hai chand ke ird-gird: I am being told that Allah the pure has written the very word Muhammad in the clouds around the moon

subhan Allah: subhan Allah

Here is a screenshot from the above video, depicting this 'miracle':

Muhammad-clouds-video.png

Comparison of Both Images

When the colors of the images are inverted as shown on the right, its easy to see how this image could have been artificially made using a graphics program.

Muhammad-moon-miracle-comparison.gif
Muhammad-moon-miracle-comparison-inverted.gif

Example of a Doctored Image

The following comparison shows how easy it is to create a 'miraculous' image:

Wikiislam-miracle-clouds.jpg
Muhammed-in-the-clouds.jpg

Other Cloud Related Images

See Also

External links

References